Why commuting needs its own approach
Employee commuting is Scope 3 category 7, one of the five categories a PPN 006 Carbon Reduction Plan must include. It is also the one with no paper trail: nobody claims expenses for getting to work, so there is nothing in your accounts to add up. That is why it is the category most often left out, and why our PPN 006 guide lists missing commuting as a common reason plans get marked down.
The fix is a short survey. You don't need every employee to answer. The GHG Protocol's Scope 3 guidance describes collecting commuting data from employees, and scaling up from a representative sample is a common, practical way to do it for a small business.
Four questions are enough
- How far is your journey to work, one way? (miles or km)
- How do you usually travel? (car, train, bus, walk or cycle, other)
- On a typical week, how many days do you travel to the workplace?
- On a typical week, how many days do you work from home?
Keep it anonymous and short, and it will get answers. If people use more than one mode, ask for the one they use for the longest part of the journey. If you want to use a better car factor, add an optional question about car size and fuel.
Getting a sample you can rely on
- Cover every site and team. A sample made up only of head office staff will miss the people who drive furthest.
- Aim for a good response rate. There is no official minimum, but the higher it is, the easier the estimate is to defend. Record the rate.
- Scale by the right number. Use headcount if most staff work full time, or full-time equivalents if many work part time.
- Write the method down. One or two sentences in your plan: when you surveyed, how many replied, and how you scaled up.
A worked example
A 40-person office business surveys its staff and gets 24 replies. Everyone works 3 days a week in the office and 2 at home, for 46 working weeks a year. Annual distance for each person is one-way distance × 2 × office days × 46. The sample totals are then multiplied by 40 ÷ 24 to cover the whole team.
| Mode | Replies | Average one way | Sample a year | Scaled to 40 staff | Factor (kg CO2e) | tCO2e |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Car, driving alone | 12 | 9 miles | 29,808 miles | 49,680 miles | 0.26699 | 13.26 |
| Train | 5 | 25 km | 34,500 passenger-km | 57,500 passenger-km | 0.03092 | 1.78 |
| Bus | 4 | 6 km | 6,624 passenger-km | 11,040 passenger-km | 0.10151 | 1.12 |
| Walk or cycle | 3 | 2 miles | 1,656 miles | 2,760 miles | 0 | 0.00 |
| Homeworking | 40 | – | – | 27,600 hours | 0.32393 | 8.94 |
| Total, category 7 | 25.10 |
Car uses the DESNZ 2026 average car (fuel unknown) factor per mile; train and bus use the national rail and average local bus factors per passenger-km; homeworking hours are 40 staff × 2 days × 7.5 hours × 46 weeks.
Two things stand out. The 12 drivers in the sample account for most of the travel emissions, even though the train users travel further, because a car carrying one person has a much higher factor per mile than a seat on a train. And homeworking is not zero: heating and powering home offices adds 8.94 tonnes, a sizeable share for a hybrid team.
Homeworking: include it or not?
The GHG Protocol treats homeworking as optional within category 7. Many UK plans include it, because leaving it out makes hybrid working look carbon-free, which it isn't. Whichever you choose, say so in the plan and keep the same approach every year so your figures stay comparable. The homeworking factor page explains what the government factor covers.
Where commuting fits
Commuting is often the largest of the five PPN 006 Scope 3 categories for an office-based firm. Our post on the five categories PPN 006 asks for shows it alongside the others, and our guide to all 15 Scope 3 categories explains where commuting ends and business travel begins.
How Carbon Recycling helps
Once you have scaled up your survey, enter the totals in Carbon Recycling: car miles under employee cars with the purpose set to commuting, rail and bus in passenger-km, and homeworking in hours. Each lands in category 7 with the right factor for the year, and the Carbon Reduction Plan flags category 7 as not measured until you do.