What happened
A report for the Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF), written by academics from the Australian National University, the University of New South Wales and others, was published on 18 November 2026. It looks at Australia's Safeguard Mechanism, which caps emissions from industrial and mining sites emitting over 100,000 tonnes CO2e a year, and at the Australian Carbon Credit Units (ACCUs) those sites can buy to cover emissions above their caps. As Adam Morton reported for the Guardian, the authors say "phantom forests" in the semi-arid outback are earning credits for forest regrowth.
The main findings, from the report itself:
- Forest cover: the authors assessed 50 human-induced regeneration (HIR) projects using satellite data. Based on the credits issued, all should have had 100% forest cover across their credited areas by late 2025. In 2025, 37% of the combined credited area had forest cover, 6 percentage points above 2020, despite a historically wet period.
- Scale: HIR projects had received almost 61 million ACCUs by 30 June 2026, including 9.3 million in 2025-26, 40% of that year's issuance. The HIR method closed to new projects in September 2023, but existing projects can keep earning credits until 2048.
- Price: the report says the supply of cheap credits has kept the ACCU price below AU$40 for most of the past eight years, which it argues weakens the incentive for covered sites to cut their own emissions.
- What the authors propose: considering excluding ACCUs from the Safeguard Mechanism, at least for a time, and letting sites pay a set price per tonne into a decarbonisation fund instead.
The ACF, which funded the research, called for coal and gas companies to be banned from using offsets to comply. The findings are disputed: Green Collar, which manages HIR projects, told the Guardian these are some of the most closely examined carbon projects in the country and that the evidence on the ground shows they are working.
What it means for your business
This is an Australian scheme, but the question is universal. UK businesses rarely buy ACCUs directly, but forest and land credits from many countries are sold on the voluntary market. The report is a reminder that a credit is only as good as the method behind it, and that measured results can fall well short of what was credited. The UK government plans to publish its own guidance on carbon credits for businesses in spring 2027, which we covered in our post on that announcement.
Your own footprint comes first, and offsets sit beside it. Under the GHG Protocol, an office using 20,000 kWh of electricity a year reports 2.62 tonnes CO2e in Scope 2 on the 2026 government factors, whether or not it buys credits. Any credits are listed separately, never subtracted. That keeps your report honest if a project you bought from is later questioned.
What to do now
- Measure and cut first. Calculate your gross Scope 1 and 2 emissions from bills and fuel, and set out real reductions before thinking about credits.
- If you buy credits, ask what's behind them: the project type, how the carbon is measured and monitored, and whether independent research supports that method. Our guide to carbon offsetting for business and our explainer on offsets versus removals cover the questions to ask.
- Be careful with claims. Avoid saying a product or business is "carbon neutral" on the strength of credits; the ASA has ruled against such claims, as in its ruling on carbon neutral delivery ads.



